Hartman Logo


Call Us Today



Firm Blog

Fighting For You, Your Children & Your Future​

You Probably Have Lots of Questions

Get answers now

Child Custody Battles in New Jersey: Best Interests of the Child

Child Custody Battles in New Jersey: Best Interests of the Child

Navigating child custody can be an emotionally charged endeavor for families, particularly when the path is unclear. Fortunately, New Jersey law provides a distinct framework prioritizing the “best interests of the child.” At Cordry Hartman, LLC, we’ve guided numerous parents through this intricate process, and in this post, we’ll demystify how New Jersey courts determine child custody.

Legal Framework for Child Custody

Child custody decisions are amongst the most critical and emotional aspects of family law. Given the stakes, it’s essential that parents understand the legal framework that guides these decisions in New Jersey. By establishing a clear framework, New Jersey aims to ensure that custody decisions prioritize the best interests of the child.

Statutory Basis

The cornerstone of child custody laws in New Jersey is the New Jersey Statutes, particularly N.J.S.A. 9:2-4. This statute makes it clear that the welfare of the child is of paramount importance. It states that children have the right to frequent and continuing contact with both parents after the parents separate or divorce. The statute then outlines the factors the court should evaluate when determining what arrangement best serves the child’s interests.

Best Interests of the Child

The “best interests of the child” principle is the driving force behind all custody decisions in New Jersey. The objective is to ensure that the child’s safety, happiness, physical, mental, and emotional welfare are prioritized. The courts take into account a variety of factors, such as:

  • Parents’ ability to cooperate and communicate regarding matters about the child.
  • Stability of the home environment.
  • Any history of domestic violence.
  • The child’s relationship with each parent.
  • The number of siblings and their relationships.
  • The child’s needs and which parent is best suited to fulfill them.

It’s important to note that no single factor is determinative. Instead, the court considers the totality of circumstances in reaching its decision.

Factors Considered in Custody Decisions

When deciding on the most suitable custody arrangement, the courts evaluate numerous factors. While it’s not a one-size-fits-all approach, these considerations ensure the child’s well-being is paramount:

Parents’ Ability to Agree, Communicate, and Cooperate

The court closely examines the relationship dynamics between the parents. Can they set aside their differences and collaborate on matters concerning the child’s welfare? Effective communication and joint decision-making are often seen as positive indicators for shared responsibilities.

Parents’ Willingness to Accept Custody

The court assesses each parent’s willingness to accept custody and any history where one parent might have unjustifiably denied the other parent access to the child. A parent’s unwarranted reluctance to facilitate a relationship between the child and the other parent can count against them.

Interaction and Relationship with Child

The emotional bond between the child and each parent, the child’s relationship with siblings, and interactions with other significant household members are all scrutinized. The goal is to understand the depth and quality of these relationships.

History of Domestic Violence

Any evidence of domestic violence, be it physical, emotional, or psychological, will be taken into account, given its potential detrimental effects on the child’s wellbeing.

Safety of the Child

The court assesses the safety of the child in each parent’s home. This includes examining living conditions, the neighborhood, and any potential threats or hazards.

Child’s Preference

Depending on the age and maturity of the child, the court might consider their preference. Generally, older children may have a say, but this is never the sole determining factor.

Needs of the Child

The court delves into the child’s unique educational, physical, and emotional needs. Which parent is better equipped or more capable of meeting these needs plays a role in the court’s decision.

Stability of Home Environment

A stable environment is critical for a child’s development. The court will evaluate the continuity of the child’s current living situation, the stability of the home setting, and how potential changes might affect the child.

Quality and Continuity of Education

The quality of the child’s current educational environment, the potential educational opportunities at each parent’s residence, and the continuity of staying in the same school or educational system are considered.

Fitness of Parents

The mental, physical, and emotional fitness of each parent is assessed. This doesn’t mean one needs to be a perfect parent but one should be fit and capable of raising a child.

Geographical Proximity

The distance between the parents’ homes can influence decisions, especially in joint custody arrangements. Proximity that supports easy commute and doesn’t disrupt the child’s routine is ideal.

Extent of Time Spent

The court reviews the time each parent spent with the child both before and after the separation.

Employment Responsibilities

The court may consider each parent’s work schedule, travel requirements, and overall employment responsibilities to assess their availability for the child.

This list isn’t exhaustive, but it provides a general idea of the thorough evaluation undertaken by the courts.

Custody Arrangement Types

In New Jersey, there are several types of custody arrangements:

  • Joint Legal Custody: Both parents have equal say in making decisions for the child, from health concerns to educational choices. However, the child might live primarily with one parent.
  • Sole Legal Custody: One parent has exclusive rights and responsibilities for making decisions concerning the child.
  • Joint Physical Custody: The child splits their time living with both parents. This arrangement requires good communication between parents.
  • Sole Physical Custody: The child lives primarily with one parent, with the other parent usually receiving visitation rights.

Parenting Time (Visitation)

Even if one parent has sole physical custody, the non-custodial parent generally retains the right to regular visitation, unless the court determines that such visitation would be against the child’s best interests. The specifics of this visitation are usually detailed in a parenting plan, which may be determined by the parents themselves or with the court’s intervention if an agreement cannot be reached.


New Jersey courts often encourage parents to engage in mediation to develop a mutually agreeable custody and parenting plan. If parents can create a plan together, it often leads to a more harmonious co-parenting relationship moving forward.

Remember, these arrangements are tailored based on the child’s best interests. What works for one family might not be suitable for another.

Contact an Experienced Family Lawyer at Cordry Hartman, LLC for a Free Consultation About Your Case Today

Child custody battles can be draining, both emotionally and mentally. However, understanding the legal landscape in New Jersey and the focus on the child’s best interests can provide clarity during uncertain times. It’s essential to remember that each family is unique, and the courts aim to ensure the child’s well-being above all else.

At Cordry Hartman, LLC, we understand the intricacies of child custody battles and are here to guide you every step of the way. If you or someone you know is navigating this challenging path, reach out to us. Let our expertise light the way to the best possible outcome for your family.